LA Times columnist urges Dianne Feinstein to resign

11 min readDec 12, 2020

Los Angeles Times columnist Erika Smith is urging Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., to resign so that California Gov. Gavin Newsom can appoint a “Black or Latino” Democrat in her place.

Feinstein was hit with a damning report from The New Yorker that alleged accusations of her “cognitive decline,” which followed severe backlash she received from the left for the hug she gave her colleague, Senate Judiciary Chairman Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., after the confirmation hearings of Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett.

In a piece published in Feinstein’s homestate paper on Thursday, Smith suggested that Newsom should be filling two vacant Senate seats instead of just the one replacing Vice President-elect Kamala Harris, which means he can appoint both a Black and Latino to the Senate instead of sacrificing one for the other.

“Representation does matter, and the more I listen to Black and Latino leaders demand it on behalf of a state that is becoming more diverse every year, the less I understand why our senior senator is still in office, blocking progress,” Smith wrote. “At 87 years old, Feinstein is the oldest member of the U.S. Senate, a member of the Silent Generation in a state dominated by people under 40. She is a wealthy woman in a state overrun with poverty, and the homelessness that too often accompanies it.”

The columnist explained, “Given all of this, it would make perfect sense for Feinstein to be selfless and retire early with California’s gratitude for a distinguished career. Now is absolutely the time to be an ally to communities of color and let another younger lawmaker represent the evolving values of this state. For to adequately address the many long-standing, race-based disparities in everything from healthcare to housing, California needs a Black senator and a Latino senator.”

While her current term doesn’t end until 2025, Feinstein has already signaled that she will step down as the ranking member of the Senate Judiciary Commitee.
Sen. Dianne Feinstein tried to fend off questions about her mental sharpness Friday after a report suggested she was “seriously struggling” with cognitive decline — but would not commit to serving out her term.

Feinstein (D-Calif.) — the oldest member of the Senate at 87 — is facing growing questions about her performance amid a tsunami of criticism over how she handled the Supreme Court confirmation hearings of Justice Amy Coney Barrett.
When asked by CNN in a congressional hallway if she would stay until her six-year term ends in 2024, Feinstein would only say: “Well, if it changes, I’ll let you know.”

Asked if she feels she is still able to carry out her duties, Feinstein said, “I do — I work hard. I have good staff. I think I am productive. And I represent the people of California as well as I possibly can,” she said.

The senator’s comments came after the New Yorker, in a report published Thursday, said Feinstein often becomes confused in meetings and forgets being briefed on a topic, “accusing her staff of failing to do so just after they have.”

“The staff is in such a bad position,” one former Senate aide told the publication. “They have to defend her and make her seem normal.”

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) has reportedly had several “painful” discussions with the octogenarian about stepping aside and even made overtures to Feinstein’s billionaire husband, Richard C. Blum.

But Feinstein reportedly soon forgets about their talks, forcing Schumer to confront her again, one source said.

“It was like ‘Groundhog Day,’ but with the pain fresh each time,” another source said.

Some people familiar with the situation blamed Schumer for not talking Feinstein out of running for re-election in 2018, with her current term due to end when she will be 91 years old. Schumer’s office did not comment.

Grumblings over Feinstein’s performance first began during the high court confirmation hearings of Justice Brett Kavanaugh in 2018 but reached a boiling point during Barrett’s confirmation — leading to Feinstein’s decision to step down last month as ranking member of the Judiciary Committee.

The lawmaker bungled several questions and then caused a furor when she ended Barrett’s hearings by hugging Judiciary Committee Chairman Lindsey Graham (R-SC) and praising him for “one of the best set of hearings that I have participated in.”

Schumer was reportedly so concerned about Feinstein’s performance that he “installed a trusted former aide, Max Young, to ’embed’ in the Judiciary Committee to make sure the hearings didn’t go off the rails,” the New Yorker reported.

When asked by CNN if she thought the report was fair, the California lawmaker responded: “No, not particularly. No one talked to me.”

Mr. Kemp rose to Georgia’s governorship with the help of President Trump, but his refusal to try to overturn the state’s election results has drawn Mr. Trump’s ire — and may affect his political future.

Few politicians have been both elevated and diminished by the vicissitudes of President Trump like Brian Kemp, the Republican governor of Georgia.

Mr. Kemp rocketed from hard-right underdog candidate to the governor’s mansion two years ago on the strength of a surprise endorsement from Mr. Trump, and an argument that the president was right about a lot of issues facing the country.

But these days Mr. Kemp is facing daily reminders of the perils of deciding that Mr. Trump is actually wrong.

In recent weeks, Mr. Kemp has infuriated the president for resisting his demands to help overturn the election results in Georgia, a state Mr. Trump lost by roughly 12,000 votes. The president’s outrage has spread to many of his supporters in Georgia as he persists in his extraordinary intervention into the nation’s electoral process.

At a news conference in the State Capitol on Tuesday to discuss the rollout of the coronavirus vaccine, Mr. Kemp was confronted by Trump loyalists asking why he had refused to call a special session of the legislature, as the president has requested, so that lawmakers can reallocate the state’s 16 electoral votes to Mr. Trump. The question crowded the screen of a Facebook live feed of the event. As he departed the event, Mr. Kemp was stopped by a small group who presented a bag that they said was filled with 2,000 petitions making the same plea.

“If he doesn’t call a special session, he’s definitely a one-term governor, no doubt about it,” said one of the activists, Erik Christensen, the chief executive of a moving company, who said he voted for Mr. Kemp in 2018.

Mr. Kemp is now the most vivid example of the battle-scarred and even shellshocked conservative Republicans who once basked in Mr. Trump’s glow but now find themselves derided for enforcing their state election rules and laws. Republican governors like Mr. Kemp and Doug Ducey of Arizona, and lower-level state officials like Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger in Georgia, have emerged as a new kind of institutionalist in the face of the Trump attacks on the election system: They are refusing to bend procedures to the will of Mr. Trump, and potentially paying a political price for it.

As Mr. Trump continues to grope for a way to undo his electoral loss to President-elect Joseph R. Biden Jr., he is also engaged in a furious effort to torpedo Mr. Kemp’s political future.

Mr. Trump has called Mr. Kemp “hapless,” mocked him for a supposed dip in popularity, and suggested, at a recent rally, that United States Representative Doug Collins should mount a primary challenge to Mr. Kemp when he seeks a second term in 2022.

“I’m ashamed that I endorsed him,” Mr. Trump said in a Fox News interview.

The president’s willingness to threaten the governor’s fervently pro-Trump voter base demonstrates how challenging it may be for Republicans to navigate a post-presidency in which the mercurial Mr. Trump could choose to play kingmaker, de facto party head and potential 2024 candidate.

Republican politicians, strategists and party officials are anxiously watching the turmoil in Georgia, fearing that the civil war the president started among Georgia’s Republicans could spread throughout the country. That would complicate the political dynamics for incumbents like Mr. Kemp, who plans to run for re-election two years from now.

In November’s election, Mr. Trump expanded the party base, driving up margins in rural areas, winning a larger share of Latino voters and capturing a record number of Republican votes. Whether those new voters will transform into loyal Republicans when Mr. Trump is not on the ticket remains one of the biggest uncertainties facing the party. And much may depend on what Mr. Trump tells Republicans to do.

“Any operative is wondering right now whether this is what the future looks like,” said Henry Barbour, a Republican committeeman from Mississippi and an influential voice in the party. “We don’t know, but the Party has a tremendous opportunity going forward to build on what the president has accomplished.”

Mr. Kemp, 57, has not been the only target of Mr. Trump’s wrath. Republican politicians and officials across the country who have defended the integrity of the election — and resisted bending to the will of the president — have faced a backlash from their own party.

In Arizona, Mr. Trump has criticized Mr. Ducey for certifying Mr. Biden’s win in that state, and suggested he would also pay a political price for it. (“Republicans will long remember!” he wrote in a recent tweet.) While term limits prevent Mr. Ducey from seeking another term, he is among those mentioned as a potential presidential contender in 2024.

On the same day that Mr. Ducey was selected to head the Republican Governors Association, Representative Andy Biggs of Arizona said Mr. Ducey had “harmed the common cause of the Republican party,” in a column on a conservative news site.

“The Duceys and the Kemps of the world, they may have some difficulty if they want to seek elective office within the Republican Party,” said Michael Burke, the chairman of the Republican Party in Pinal County in Arizona. “People will remember what happened here,” added Mr. Burke, who worked at Mr. Trump’s properties before becoming involved with politics.

Mr. Trump launched fresh attacks on Twitter Saturday morning. “Who is a worse governor, @BrianKempGA of Georgia or @dougducey of Arizona???” he wrote. “These are two RINO Republicans who fought against me and the Republican Party harder than any Democrat. They allowed states that I won easily to be stolen. Never forget, vote them out of office!”

Allies of the president had already begun issuing veiled threats toward Mr. Kemp, warning that what they see as his insufficient loyalty to the president could carry a political price.

“If you’re not fighting for Trump now when he needs you the most as a Republican leader in Georgia, people are not going to fight for you when you ask them to get re-elected,” said Senator Lindsey Graham, of South Carolina, in an appearance on Fox News.

Democrats are trying to exploit these divisions. MeidasTouch, a progressive national political committee, announced plans this week to put up billboards in Georgia emblazoned with a Trump tweet that reads, “Why bother voting for Republicans if what you get is Ducey and Kemp?” Mr. Biden plans to travel to the state next week to campaign for the two Democratic candidates, who would give his party control of the Senate if they won runoffs against Republican incumbents on Jan. 5.

Mr. Kemp’s descent from Mr. Trump’s circle of approval is particularly striking. Throughout his career, he has taken pains to demonstrate his conservative credentials: In one particularly unsubtle ad that ran during his 2018 run for governor, titled “So Conservative,” he demonstrated his desire to “blow up government spending” with actual explosives, and “cut regulations” with a real chain saw.

It was Mr. Trump’s positive tweet just days before the Republican primary runoff that helped Mr. Kemp gain the nomination. Then in the general election, Mr. Kemp became one of the Trump era’s most enduring villains in the eyes of the left after his narrow victory over Stacey Abrams, who was vying to become the nation’s first Black woman governor.

Ms. Abrams and her allies argued that Mr. Kemp, then the secretary of state, engineered a “stolen” election by supporting policies that Democrats said amounted to voter suppression and in some cases targeted minorities.

Since then, much of Mr. Kemp’s political personality had been borrowed directly from Mr. Trump. Billing himself as a “politically incorrect conservative,” Mr. Kemp has echoed Mr. Trump’s hyperbolic message about the violent threats illegal immigrants pose to American citizens.

Despite his rhetoric, Mr. Kemp has not played the role of radical disrupter the way doctrinaire former Republican governors like Sam Brownback of Kansas or Bobby Jindal of Louisiana did. But he has delivered for his conservative base by supporting and signing an anti-abortion “heartbeat” law, which was permanently enjoined by the courts.

Other policy actions, including a raise for public schoolteachers, and a slew of appointments reflecting the state’s burgeoning diversity, suggest some movement on Mr. Kemp’s part toward a practical center. But much of that has been overshadowed by criticism of his reopening of the state in the early stages of the coronavirus pandemic and his conflicts with the Democratic mayor of Atlanta, Keisha Lance Bottoms, including over her efforts to implement a mask mandate.

Still, this generally conservative track record has not stemmed the torrent of criticism that is currently engulfing the governor from the right. Nor have Mr. Kemp’s delicate — or perhaps awkward — efforts to praise Mr. Trump while steadfastly declining to give him the overturned election results he wants. At the news conference on Tuesday, for instance, Mr. Kemp talked about how “grateful” he was for the Trump administration’s “unprecedented and incredible achievement” of making the vaccine available.

A Republican consultant in Georgia familiar with Mr. Kemp’s thinking said that while the governor agrees with many of Mr. Trump’s policies, the president’s request that he work to overturn the election — a request Mr. Trump made in a phone call with the governor last weekend — crossed a line.

Mr. Kemp’s office declined to make him available for an interview.

Mr. Kemp’s relationship with the president began to seriously deteriorate late last year when he defied Mr. Trump’s wishes and appointed Kelly Loeffler, a wealthy Atlanta businesswoman, to an open Senate seat. Ms. Loeffler and Senator David Perdue are the Republican candidates in the Georgia runoffs in January.

Mr. Kemp will have to run on a ticket in 2022 with whoever wins the Senate seat. By choosing Ms. Loeffler, he was most likely trying to craft the image of the state Republican Party in a way that he thought would reflect Georgia’s evolving politics: a female candidate who he believed could win back more moderate voters in Atlanta’s populous northern suburbs. He also considered Ms. Loeffler, a political novice, a good fit for his brand, which he considers to be pro-business, outside the establishment and conservative.

Mr. Trump preferred that the Senate seat go to Mr. Collins, the conservative Georgia Republican who had passionately defended Mr. Trump against impeachment. Mr. Collins subsequently jumped into this year’s race, losing in the first round of voting but pushing Ms. Loeffler far to the right to prove her conservative bona fides.

A similar dynamic could emerge if Mr. Trump backs a primary challenger in the 2022 governor’s race. That could lead Mr. Kemp to lurch rightward after he has made some effort to move to the center. Such a shift might help Ms. Abrams, who may challenge Mr. Kemp in a rematch.

But all of these projections are clouded with questions about the president himself. Will he get involved in 35 local and statewide races, or concentrate on two or three? Will he settle old scores? Mr. Kemp’s political future may depend on the answer.

“I’m 100 percent Donald Trump. I’m 100 percent Brian Kemp,” said former Representative Jack Kingston, Republican of Georgia and a Trump ally. “I believe it’s just something that we’ve got to get through.”

LA Times columnist urges Dianne Feinstein to resign

Written by Super Bowl